Okay, this is a DIRECT QUOTE from your book FH Chapter 29...as I continue to read it, I will post with more of my thoughts versus yours. Again, not here to cause trouble...just to offer a different point of view so that the forum readers can decide on their own about this theory.
"Let’s begin by revisiting a parable through which Yahshua described His kingdom: "Again, the kingdom of heaven is like a dragnet that was cast into the sea and gathered some of every kind [literally: family], which, when it was full, they drew to shore; and they sat down and gathered the good into vessels, but threw the bad away. So it will be at the end of the age. The angels will come forth, separate the wicked from among the just, and cast them into the furnace of fire. There will be wailing and gnashing of teeth." (Matthew 13:47-50) It’s disturbing enough to find that "bad fish" are swimming with the "good" ones, though we saw this very thing in the parables of the mustard seed and the wheat and tares. These "bad fish" can even be found within the nominal church, as Yahshua made all too obvious in His seven letters in Revelation 2 and 3.
But there’s more here than meets the eye. A subtle differentiation between two types of "bad fish" in this passage is totally lost in the English, a distinction that is important to our understanding of mankind’s prospective eternal destinies. The fish that were characterized as "bad" are simply "thrown away." By contrast, "wicked" fish are "cast into the furnace of fire" where there will be "wailing and gnashing of teeth." We ordinarily assume these are the same souls, but they’re not. The word translated "bad" is the Greek sapros. It means rotten and decayed, putrefied, decomposed, thus unfit and worthless. A fish that is sapros is dead, and judging by the stench, has been for some time. "Wicked," on the other hand, is the Greek word poneros, meaning one causing pain, peril, and trouble, someone who is diseased, malignant, seriously faulty, evil, morally corrupt, vicious, even one who derives his wickedness from supernatural evil powers. Fish that are poneros are very much alive--and they’re dangerous. Thus there are not two but three kinds of fish: the good, the lifeless, and the evil. And there are three corresponding potential destinies: (1) eternal life with Yahweh (a very good thing), (2) death (a bad thing), and (3) everlasting punishment like that reserved for Satan and his demons (something infinitely worse than bad). "
Now, in this text, you have twisted the scripture to your point of view. The verse talks about fishermen getting rid of bad fish and keeping the good fish. That's TWO piles of fish, not three. The verse does NOT seperate the bad fish into two catagories. Again, in the further verse, the angels come and separate the wicked from the just--again, TWO "piles" not three. Again, the "wicked" are not divided into two separate catagories--it is talked about as one catagory. The scripture is using "bad" and "wicked" as the same thing in order to show the reader that there are TWO paths, one to the furnace of fire and one to heaven. ONLY by you trying to break up the story (thus destroying its intent of using an example that the people would understand [the fishermen] to describe a future event [the angels])--and add a third "pile" that is not written about--can you come up with the three door theology using this story.
"The word translated "bad" is the Greek sapros. It means rotten and decayed, putrefied, decomposed, thus unfit and worthless. A fish that is sapros is dead,..." An apple can be decaying or decomposing on an apple tree...still alive, but dying. You are ASSUMING that the fish are dead, they could just be sickly. If "unfit and worthless" is the Greek and not your interpretation, then a "worthless fish or unfit fish" simply could mean that it is too small, diseased, etc. and not fit to eat, thus not fit to keep. An "unfit" person is also a "wicked" person (because of sin) and will be cast into the fire. A "just" person is one who is "justified by faith" in Yashua.
You're trying too hard to make the scriptures "fit" your theory. Anyone can plainly realize what Yashua meant by the parable...if He was talking about a third pile (of fish) or option, He would have stated it plainly because He was teaching uneducated people. He wanted the uneducated people to understand what He was talking about, thus He utilized terminology they would understand in that day to reveal what would happen in the future. If there were a third option, He would have said that the fishermen put the bad fish in one pile, the wicked fish (?? lol) in another pile, and the good fish in yet a third pile. The bad fish were thrown away, the wicked fish were burned in the fire, and the good fish were kept. See? "Bad" fish and "Wicked" fish were meant to be the same thing.
More of MY opinion to come as I continue to read FH Chapter 29...